The South Carolina Supreme Court ruled on April 4, 2012 in 16 Jade Street v. R. Design Co., LLC, et al. ruled that a member of a limited liability company, or LLC, can be held personally liability for torts committed while acting on behalf of the company’s business.
16 Jade Street, LLC was the property owner that entered into a contract with general contractor, R. Design Construction Co., LLC for the construction of a four-unit condo project. RDC was owned by its members, Carl Aten and his wife. Aten held a residential home builders license. Aten subbed out part of the work to Catterson & Sons Construction, a corporation, for framing and block installation. Michael Catterson was the sole shareholder of Catterson & Sons. Catterson himself did not perform any construction, but served as a liaison between his foreman and his own workers. Problems arose with the quality of work by Catterson and following a payment dispute, Catterson withdrew from the job. Aten did repair the defects quickly and RDC eventually left the project. A new general contractor was hired to finish the project. Jade Street subsequently sued RDC, Aten individually, Catterson & Sons, and Catterson individually for breach of contract, negligence, and breach of implied warranties.
Aten argued that he was personally shielded for his ordinary negligence as an LLC member by the provisions of the Uniform Limited Liability Company Act as enacted in South Carolina. The Supreme Court was not swayed by this argument even though it admitted that the statute appeared to provide such protection. The court cited the following arguments:
Here are the practical implications of the court’s holding for each individual:
This ruling has caused an outcry from the South Carolina building community. However, this has been the case law for many years as regards incorporation by builders. This is how I have always explained things to my clients:
As a result, builders will need to look to their General Liability policy for protection against lawsuits that involve their own active negligence. As for construction defect claims, Exclusion CG2294 can be a big problem for builders.
See our other articles for strategies to deal with this exclusion:
3014 Devine St.
P.O. Box 5866
Columbia, SC 29250
1-800-622-7370 Toll Free